Jump to content

The Protestant Community

Christian and Theologically Protestant? Or, sincerely inquiring about the Protestant faith? Welcome to Christforums the Christian Protestant community. You'll first need to register in order to join our community. Create or respond to threads on your favorite topics and subjects. Registration takes less than a minute, it's simple, fast, and free! Enjoy the fellowship! God bless, Christforums' Staff
Register now

Fenced Community

Christforums is a Protestant Christian forum, open to Bible-believing Christians such as Presbyterians, Lutherans, Reformed, Baptists, Church of Christ members, Pentecostals, Anglicans. Methodists, Charismatics, or any other conservative, Nicene- derived Christian Church. We do not solicit cultists of any kind, including Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, Eastern Lightning, Falun Gong, Unification Church, Aum Shinrikyo, Christian Scientists or any other non-Nicene, non-Biblical heresy.
Register now

Christian Fellowship

John Calvin puts forward a very simple reason why love is the greatest gift: “Because faith and hope are our own: love is diffused among others.” In other words, faith and hope benefit the possessor, but love always benefits another. In John 13:34–35 Jesus says, “A new command I give you: Love one another. As I have loved you, so you must love one another. By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you love one another.” Love always requires an “other” as an object; love cannot remain within itself, and that is part of what makes love the greatest gift.
Sign in to follow this  
thatbrian

Tim Keller | Our Identity: The Christian Alternative to Late Modernity's Story

Recommended Posts

Staff

I viewed the video in entirety, and haven't anything to add. Thanks for sharing thatbrian.

 

God bless,

William

Share this post


Link to post
I viewed the video in entirety, and haven't anything to add. Thanks for sharing thatbrian.

 

God bless,

William

 

 

No discussion? No questions?

Share this post


Link to post
Staff

 

 

No discussion? No questions?

 

Alright thatbrian, for the sake of fellowship, brother...

 

Honestly, I was searching for something new, but nothing really came from Keller's talk that hit me. He went over what I already knew when finding myself several years ago while identity searching. It was nice hearing him or another say what I discovered, but at the same time I was unclear as to whether Keller's soteriology promotes autonomy? Even if, I'm sure lots of people especially young people will benefit from Keller's talk.

 

When I was disabled years ago, I really lost myself. I never realized up until that time how much I identified myself in the ways he depicted, by my success, material excess, and my job. When I lost my job and my material "wealth" house, cars, boats, motorcycles, and then wife, I really hit rock bottom, saying I'll live under a bridge and eat dog food. And I meant it. I even showed up at my divorce hearing totally drunk and high because I didn't want to live through that situation.

 

I withdrew from society for years thereafter, even doing grocery shopping at 2am to avoid human contact. I have experienced multiple psychosis over the years, including verbal and visual hallucinations, most definitely induced from my mental illness compounded with a drug dependency etc. My drug dependency really was a game of Russian Roulette every time I got high due to the severity of the drug and the nature of my addiction. I put a gun up to my head more than once, and I prayed and prayed and prayed that God take my life, and rid me of this miserable existence, but like so often God knows best in His wisdom, and He took my life in ways I never expected.

 

Throughout my lows when having nothing I discovered I had everything through Christ. I never looked at my identity as being a father, a good son, a law abiding citizen having solidarity with our nation though I served my country. Everything was meaningless to me. But what Keller skipped over initially, I realized, though, I am not worthy, Christ my beloved had died for me.

 

I really was a violent person up until my early thirties, having pleasured myself in physically hurting others and I surrounded myself with a social circle of some very bad people. Amazing, some say an alcoholic shouldn't preach in bars, but literally, I began uncontrollably talking bout God before some notorious local drug dealers - and I was one of them.

 

My new identity really never took shape until I moved away from where my bad reputation was established. I literally stepped away from everyone, even changing my name. I have resisted the urge now several years later even to go back for my friends. I have nothing in common with some people anymore, though I entertain a feeling in my heart that suggest what if they too were called? My new identity in Christ is everything, nothing means more to me than that. Not being American or a Constitutional Republican, etc, I really understood what Keller said when he talked about the married man that said the two most important days in his life was the day he was baptized and the other the vows taken in a marriage covenant.

 

Today, I find no worth in my personal identity, but I find value in serving Christ, for my service, I must say, though insignificant as it is through my eyes, I hope to hear from our beloved - "faithful servant". If anything, what scares me today and brings fear and trembling is the thought that I may not persevere to the last day? What if this is like so many fads that took me in my life and gave me purpose only temporarily?

 

Your thoughts on the video?

 

God bless,

William

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post

 

Alright thatbrian, for the sake of fellowship,

 

Honestly, I was searching for something new, but nothing really came from Keller's talk that hit me. He went over what I already knew when finding myself several years ago while identity searching. It was nice hearing him or another say what I discovered, but at the same time I was unclear as to whether Keller's soteriology promotes autonomy?

 

When I was disabled years ago, I really lost myself. I never realized up until that time how much I identified myself in the ways he depicted, my success, and my job. When I lost my job and my material "wealth" I really hit rock bottom, saying I'll live under a bridge and eat dog food. I withdrew from society for years, even doing grocery shopping at 2am to avoid human contact. Throughout my lows when having nothing I discovered I had everything through Christ. I never looked at my identity as being a father, a good son, a law abiding citizen having solidarity with our nation though I served my country. Everything was meaningless to me. But what Keller skipped over initially, I realized, though, I am not worthy, Christ my beloved had died for me.

 

My new identity really never took shape until I moved away from where my bad reputation was established. I literally stepped away from everyone, even changing my name. My new identity is in Christ, nothing means more to me than that. I really understood what Keller said when he talked about the married man that said the two most important days in his life was the day he was baptized and the other a marriage covenant.

 

Your thoughts on the video?

 

God bless,

William

 

 

I'm glad that you have realized what most don't. It often, if not always, takes pain and suffering to come to understand these things.

 

Obviously I thought his talk to those students was great. It's great in that it exposes something that most aren't aware of. I would venture a guess that you still find your identity, to some degree, in something other than Christ. I know that I do, which is why I find this talk helpful. Its message never gets old to me.

 

Often when people come to faith they simply shift where they find their identity from one thing to another. Pastors can find their identity in numbers. Missionaries can also fall into the same trap. People can go from drug addicts to preachers, yet still not place the weight of their souls fully on Christ. Think of those who will say, Lord, Lord, didn't we. . . The human heart is an idol factory, as Calvin said. What Keller brings out so well is that idols can be, and almost always are "good" things. Children, spouse, home, career. . . these are among the idols that can destroy, if their importance is disordered - if their place is not subordinate to God.

 

Maybe you've licked this problem. That certainly is possible; however, maybe you don't realize how subtle and insidious this problem is. Hopefully i's the former.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Staff

 

 

I'm glad that you have realized what most don't. It often, if not always, takes pain and suffering to come to understand these things.

 

Obviously I thought his talk to those students was great. It's great in that it exposes something that most aren't aware of. I would venture a guess that you still find your identity, to some degree, in something other than Christ. I know that I do, which is why I find this talk helpful. Its message never gets old to me.

 

Often when people come to faith they simply shift where they find their identity from one thing to another. Pastors can find their identity in numbers. Missionaries can also fall into the same trap. People can go from drug addicts to preachers, yet still not place the weight of their souls fully on Christ. Think of those who will say, Lord, Lord, didn't we. . . The human heart is an idol factor, as Calvin said. What Keller brings out so well is that idols can be, and almost always are "good" things. Children, spouse, home, career. . . these are among the idols that can destroy, if they are discorded - if their place is not subordinate to God.

 

Maybe you licked this problem. That certainly is possible; however, maybe you don't realize how subtle and insidious this problem is. Hopefully i's the former.

 

Ya know, one of the things I thought pretty nifty when studying Buddhism long ago was the great struggle against attachments which leads to undue suffering. Attachments can even be formed in relationships, and not only materialism. I found this in the Lord's prayer, and for a period of time tried to lose the words "I, me, myself" even from my own vocabulary. It actually took me a few years to use those words that identify me again. You're right, my identity shifted from an individualistic idea to the body of Christ where I find solidarity. Keller touched upon this subject, and explained it very well.

 

I think most people discover this kinda thing once they retire.

 

God bless,

William

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
I think most people discover this kinda thing once they retire.

 

It's discovered when something is lost or threatened. For example, you might not realize how much of your identity was wrapped up in your career until you are unemployed. It's perfectly normal to be down or anxious if you are out of work, but I personally know someone who committed suicide after being laid off. His career was his "life". When he lost his career, he lost his life. He lost who he was - his identity.

 

 

“Our need for worth is so powerful that whatever we base our identity and value on we essentially 'deify.' We will look to it with all the passion and intensity of worship and devotion, even if we think ourselves as highly irreligious. ” ― Timothy Keller

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Topics

    • 'Criticism of Christian Education in America Should Stop,' Vice President Pence Defends His Wife amid Media Backlash

      Vice President Mike Pence’s wife was the target of criticism this week after she announced that she would be teaching art at a private conservative Christian school, and the Vice President is stepping up to defend her. View the full article

      in Christian Current Events

    • Gnostic Christian

      I am a Gnostic Christian and tend to not last long in Christian sites.   I guess that the reason for that is the same as it was when the early Christian church decimated us and burned our scripture.   They could not take criticism well or argue against us in a reasonable way and chose to kill us instead.   Can those here, including the mods handle criticism?   I do try to be as civil as possible but know that even civil criticism is not tolerated well in many Christian sites   Thoughts?   Regards DL

      in Exploring Christianity

    • How to Form a Christian Mind in a Digital World

      Many have rightly warned that evangelicals are losing “a Christian mind” by neglecting the Bible and indiscriminately consuming secular materials informed by non-Christian ideas. But what if it’s not just the content we consume but also the medium in which we read it that poses a danger to our minds? In Reader, Come Home: The Reading Brain in a Digital World, Maryanne Wolf makes a compelling case that our use of digital devices is changing the way we read, which in turn is profoundly altering the way we think—a chilling prospect for Christians, who believe that through his written Word, God renews our minds, enabling us to think in sanctified ways. Digital Challenges Although Wolf—a Tufts University professor who has studied the neurological processes involved in the act of reading—has no such spiritual concerns, she believes the stakes in our transition from a print to a digital culture are incredibly high. Again and again she confronts her readers with sobering questions: “Will new readers develop the more time-demanding cognitive processes nurtured by print-based mediums as they absorb and acquire new cognitive capacities emphasized by digital media?” “Will our youth develop such a passive response to knowledge that eventually the store of what they know and their ability to connect it through analogy and inference will be depleted?” “Will the combination of reading on digital formats and daily immersion in a variety of digital experiences . . . impede the formation of the slower cognitive processes such as critical thinking, personal reflection, imagination, and empathy that are part of deep reading?” “Will the quality of our attention change as we read on mediums that advantage immediacy, dart-quick task switching, and continuous monitoring of distraction . . . ?” Wolf obviously sees a strong possibility that the answers to these questions might be yes. The reason? In her early research, she studied what happens within the brain when we read. Eventually she became concerned about “how the circuitry of the reading brain would be altered by the unique characteristics of the digital medium, particularly in the young.” Her conclusion is that since the advent of the digital age, “we have already begun to change how we read—with all of its many implications for how we think.” Reading Brain On the opening page of the book, Wolf declares provocatively that “human beings were never born to read,” by which she means that reading isn’t something our brains are hardwired to do, such as seeing or communicating. Rather, reading is “an unnatural cultural invention” that we must learn. This we’re able to do since our brain cells can make myriad connections, leading to the formation in each emerging reader of a “reading circuit” that links centers of the brain concerned with such crucial tasks as vision, language, cognition, motor functions, and affective functions. However, she warns that digital devices pose a threat to the development of this mental circuitry—not because digital reading is fundamentally different from print reading, but because the digital medium deluges us with information in byte-sized chunks, promoting information overload and distraction. As evidence, Wolf notes that students today are demonstrating “diminishing familiarity with conceptually demanding prose.” Wolf sees numerous dangers here: shrinking attention spans that preclude “deep reading” (her term for focused, thoughtful reading), which in turn leads to failure to gain the empathy for others that reading engenders and the kind of personal store of knowledge that enables inference, deduction, and analogical thinking. Christians might perceive an overarching danger: a reduction in our ability to grasp God’s truth through deep reading of his Word. Clearly God created us with the capacity to learn the complex process of reading so that we might benefit from his written revelation, the Bible. But the Word of God is a challenging book, a prime example of “conceptually demanding prose” that requires attentive, reflective reading. Are we willing to let our digital pottage make us poorer students of this treasure? Reader Recommendations What is to be done? Wolf’s recommendation isn’t simply that young readers be denied exposure to digital devices—indeed, she is surprisingly open to their use—but that such exposure be meted out in careful doses. She urges parents of children up to age 5 to read to them often, giving them little access to digital devices. “Human interaction and physical interaction with books and print are the best entry into the world of oral and written language and internalized knowledge, the building blocks of the later reading circuit,” she writes. As for children 5 to 10 years of age, Wolf wants them develop a “biliterate brain” by learning in both print and digital mediums. Physical books are her preferred tool for reading instruction, while digital devices might be used to teach coding, programming, and creative skills such as graphic arts and musical composition. In other words, she envisions a two-track learning approach, with the understanding that students can safely combine print and digital media only when their mental reading circuits are firmly established around fourth grade. Thereafter, the goal is to prevent those circuits from atrophying. Digital Wisdom Whether many schools would agree to adopt such an approach, there is wisdom here for Christian parents, who must always be their children’s prime educators. If you’re a parent, read the Bible to your children from an early age, along with age-appropriate Bible storybooks and well-written (and well-illustrated) children’s books. As they grow, introduce them to classic literary works. Let them hear both biblical truth and also beautiful language. Through the exhausting early years of child-rearing, fight the terrible temptation to let a smartphone or tablet serve as a babysitter, much as parents a generation ago had to resist the siren song of TV. Keep books in your home for this purpose, whether owned or borrowed from the local library. Don’t let down your guard as your children acquire the ability to read for themselves. Help them find books that appeal to their expanding interests. When the time is right, these might include eBooks, but as much as possible help them use digital devices as tools for specific purposes, not as toys for relieving boredom. Hopefully by these means, we can raise up children who will be able to read and appreciate challenging texts, especially the Scriptures, which unfold the gospel of salvation through Christ. Meanwhile, we adults will do well to guard our own minds from the degenerative effects of the digital world. If Wolf is right—and her research seems sound and well-attested—such digital discipline is crucial for Christians who want to grow in their knowledge of God and his truth. View the full article

      in Christian Current Events

    • Former Porn Star Turned Christian Counselor Shares How God Changed Her Life

      Crystal DiGregorio is sharing a message of grace and forgiveness by telling her story of how she went from a porn star to a Christian counselor. View the full article

      in Christian Current Events

    • Media Astonished To Learn Christian School Teaches Christian Beliefs

      U.S.—News media outlets around the country were reportedly astonished to discover a Christian school at which second lady Karen Pence is teaching holds their students and staff to Christian beliefs. The post Media Astonished To Learn Christian School Teaches Christian Beliefs appeared first on The Babylon Bee. View the original full article

      in Christian Satire

×

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.